Q+A :: How to Respond to a Mean Pastor
QUESTION:
As a lay-leader in my church, I have recently found out how poorly our senior pastor treats most of the other staff “behind the scenes.” Two of the staff members are thinking of quitting.
He is very good at manipulating information and opinions, so I am not sure how our elders board would react if I were to approach them about it.
I don’t feel that I am in a position to confront him, plus I really do not handle conflict well. Some amazing, good things are happening at our church, but I don’t think this undercurrent of antagonism within the leadership can go unchecked. It is seriously affecting some very talented ministry workers and making them doubt their own callings and abilities. Any suggestions?
- Sarah :: Canada
ANSWER:
Unfortunately, some churches have mean pastors. It is a leadership flaw that hurts the church, even when the church appears to be thriving. In your case, it sounds like your pastor hurts the people doing the most vital work, which certainly affects the quality of their work. Sadly, too many Christians can relate to your story.
I have heard plenty of stories, including one church where the staff and even the volunteers were in constant fear of being fired (yes, they fired volunteers and sometimes in bulk). It noticeably affected church workers. In fact, one churchgoer who stayed described the volunteering experience as:
I feel like it is an abusive marriage. I get mistreated, but I still keep coming back.
- Anonymous Churchgoer
I can not give you a perfect formula for how to respond to a mean pastor because there is no universal cause for pastoral meanness. But I can give you some ideas that might work.
- Pray
Above all else, pray. Pray for your mean pastor. Pray for personal guidance. How should you handle the situation? Should you confront the leader? Should you stay at that church? - Confront
Confrontation is ideal. Matthew 18:15-22 is a good guide to confrontation. A strong leader can handle constructive confrontation, particularly from their core workers. But some leaders will fire you for confronting them, and some will go as far as banning you from their church (no joke). - Ignore It & Focus
Some people do well ignoring the negatives and focusing on how to improve what they do. It is tough, but I have seen it work. - Leave
If you do not feel called by God to be attending and serving that church, leave and find a church that can be a better steward of your abilities. If you are called to that church, than you stay there, constantly pray, and then confront it, ignore it, or both (if confronting does not work).
Most importantly, guard against bitterness and forgive your mean pastor so that you can be in right standing with God (Matthew 6:15).
For Discussion:
- What advice do you have for responding to a mean pastor?
If you have a question you want Church Relevance to answer, submit it via our Q+A form.














